Murder victim Henry Neudorf of Tilbury. (Photo via Facebook)
Windsor

Crown rests its case in Tilbury murder trial

The murder trial of Kim Price heard more testimony on Thursday from two more people close to the Henry Neudorf murder, but one witness was nearly derailed.

Price is on trial for Neudorf's murder in Tilbury on January 11, 2024.

Neudorf's roommate, Jasmine Hill-Gray, told Chatham Superior Court on Thursday she remembers Price's son, David Trealout, ambushing Neudorf, whacking him in the head with a cast iron frying pan, and laughing afterwards when Neudorf lost control of his bowels.

Hill-Gray also corroborated previous testimony that Price and her son smothered Neudorf after he got bashed in the head and that Price later called police to get her son arrested.

She testified that she heard Price and Trealout planning how to murder Neudorf. However, she later said the murder was Trealout's idea, adding that Price put garbage bags in place and duct-taped everyone's footwear to hide tracks.

During cross-examination, the defence noted she never told police about the smothering, the duct-taping of footwear, or the garbage bags used during the murder.

Another witness, Robert Auckland, a former boyfriend of Price, testified that Trealout admitted to killing Neudorf and, in an effort to end the ordeal, he and Price later arranged to have all four roommates arrested the day after the murder.

Auckland also told the court that Trealout had assaulted family members many times in the past, that he needs institutional help, and that he manipulates the system to prevent getting the help he needs.

Before Hill-Gray testified, a lengthy debate took place about whether her testimony was reliable because of her "significant" mental health issues.

Assistant Crown Melanie Nancekievill told the court that Hill-Gray is too unreliable, too distracted, and can't assist the court with the trial.

Toronto defence lawyer Ari Goldkind accused the prosecution of trying to keep testimony from the court to help her case, adding Hill-Gray should be called to the stand.

Goldkind asked why Hill-Gray was being pulled from the witness list when Trealout wasn't, despite all of his equally significant mental health issues.

He also questioned if the move by the Crown to exclude Hill-Gray was to conceal evidence to gain a tactical or strategic advantage.

Nancekievill said she was offended by Goldkind's accusations, adding the Hill-Gray consideration was about the witness' credibility.

Nancekievill said she's never seen anything like this trial.

Justice Bruce Thomas ultimately decided that Hill-Gray could take the stand and testify, adding that all witnesses in this trial are vulnerable.

Thomas noted he's not sure if any evidence given at this trial is factual, adding that it's important if the ruling is appealed.

The Crown rested its case on Thursday afternoon.

Closing submissions will be presented on Wednesday and Thursday.

Read More Local Stories